Google Ads · Lead Quality
Bad Google Ads Leads: How to Spot and Fix Them
You've just paid for a lead or a call through Google Ads, and it was a complete waste of time. Wrong postcode, a tyre kicker, a silent call, or someone who was never going to spend €500 on your service. The question every business owner asks at this point is simple: was that a genuinely bad lead, or is this just normal, and what can I actually do about it?
Here's the honest answer. Some bad leads are Google's fault, some are your website's fault, and some are just the cost of doing business. The trick is telling the three apart, because the fix (and whether you can get any money back) is completely different for each.
First, understand what Google actually refunds
Google has two separate systems, and mixing them up causes most of the frustration.
- Invalid clicks: these are clicks Google's own systems think came from bots, accidental double clicks, or click fraud. If caught before your bill closes, you're simply never charged. If caught after billing, you get a credit on a future bill, labelled "Invalid activity" under Billing. This is never cash back to your card.
- Local Services Ads lead credits: if you use pay-per-lead Local Services Ads, Google automatically reviews charged leads and can credit ones it judges invalid, usually within about 30 days. You can also rate a lead yourself through the Leads page to flag it as spam, a wrong number, or outside your area.
How to tell a "bad lead" from a "wasted click"
Run through this checklist before you assume fraud or blame Google:
- Check the basics first. Most "bad leads" are actually broad keywords, vague ad copy, or a confusing landing page pulling in the wrong people, not fraud. If your ad says "boiler repair" but you're bidding on "boiler jobs near me," you'll get people hunting for work, not customers.
- Look for a pattern, not a one-off. One rubbish lead a week is normal. A sudden spike in junk from one campaign, especially with clicks that don't show up as engaged visits in Google Analytics, is worth investigating.
- Check the source. If the junk leads cluster on "Search Partners" rather than Google Search itself, that's a targeting setting you can simply switch off, not something to dispute.
- Check for real signs of invalid traffic: repeat clicks from the same source with zero engagement, clicks from areas you don't target, or a GA4 session count that doesn't match your Google Ads click count. These are the signals worth raising with Google.
There's no official "normal" rate for bad leads. Google itself says there's no industry standard for invalid traffic. The useful approach is to track your own baseline over 8 to 12 weeks, then investigate properly when a week looks far worse than that baseline.
What you can actually do about it
Google only investigates invalid click claims from the previous 60 days, so don't sit on it. Gather dates, the campaign, and anything unusual like repeated identical enquiries. Submit this through Google's invalid activity reporting tool. Expect a 4 to 8 week wait for a manual review, and treat any credit as a bonus, not a guarantee.
If you use pay-per-lead leads, use the Lead Feedback Survey on every single lead, even the good ones. This feeds Google's system, can trigger automatic credits, and over time improves the quality of leads it sends you. Be specific about why a lead was invalid (spam, duplicate, wrong number) rather than "not a good fit," since Google no longer credits leads just because the customer wanted a job type or area you don't cover.
Google's invalid traffic system only covers what happens before someone lands on your site. Fake form submissions, bot spam, and people typing nonsense into your contact form are entirely your responsibility to filter. Three things that genuinely help:
- A simple CAPTCHA or honeypot field on your enquiry form to block bots. This stops a huge share of pure spam submissions for free.
- Double opt-in confirmation. Send an automatic email with a confirmation link, and only treat the enquiry as a real lead once it's clicked. Genuine customers click it within minutes; bots and tyre kickers usually don't.
- A qualifying question on the form itself. Ask about budget range, postcode, or timeframe before someone can submit. This filters out mismatched enquiries before they ever reach your phone.
If you're reviewing leads and finding a repeating pattern, such as enquiries from outside your service area or for a job type you don't offer, that's a targeting fix, not a Google dispute. Add negative keywords for the job types you don't do, exclude locations outside your patch, and if Search Partners are the source of most junk, turn that setting off.
It's tempting to mark every dud lead as "not a conversion" and move on. Be careful: if you're using Smart Bidding, Google's algorithm learns from what you tell it counts as a conversion. If you flag genuine but low-value leads as failures just because they didn't close, you can confuse the algorithm into chasing the wrong audience. Instead, feed back real outcomes (booked job, not booked) through offline conversion imports where you can, so the system learns what you actually want more of.
The bottom line
Most "bad leads" aren't fraud, they're a mismatch between what your ad promises, what your form asks, and what your campaign is targeting. Genuine invalid activity is real but relatively rare, and Google will only ever credit it, never hand back cash. The leverage you actually have is in tightening your targeting, filtering your forms, and rating every lead honestly so the system learns. That's where the real money gets saved.
If you want someone to look at your campaigns and work out where the junk leads are actually coming from, book a free call and we'll go through your account together.
Book a Free Call